The Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil was released around 2018, but started getting attention after celebrities started reaching for it in their makeup routines. Hailey Bieber helped put shades like Anywhere Caffeine and Wherever Walnut on everyone’s radar with her signature lip combos, and Jennifer Lopez later used one in her Vogue Beauty Secrets video. Suddenly, this long-time makeup artist favourite was everywhere again.
As a freelance beauty editor, I get to test a lot of new makeup, so it takes something pretty special for an older product to stay in my collection. I’ve been using the Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil for a while now, and after pairing it with lip glosses, lipsticks, and wearing it on its own, here’s my honest review—and whether I think it’s still worth the hype.
How It Wears:
Despite going viral as a lip liner, the Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil is actually a multi-purpose pencil designed for use on the eyes, lips, cheeks, and face. That’s part of what makes it such a great product—you can get creative with how you use it.
Personally, I use shades Anywhere Caffeine and Limitless Brown on my waterline or blend them out for a quick eyeshadow look, while Boundless Berry makes for a nice blush shade. Endless Cacao makes a great contour shade. Of course, I love to use them as lip liners. The formula is creamy, so it glides onto the skin without tugging, but once it sets, it has impressive staying power.
Who Would Like This Product?
If you love a precise, sharp lip liner, the Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil is definitely worth checking out. The pencil makes it easy to create clean, defined edges while the creamy formula glides on smoothly without skipping.
You’ll also love it if you prefer multi-purpose products. Since it’s designed to be used on the lips, eyes, cheeks, and face, it’s a great option for anyone who likes getting more versatility out of their makeup. It’s no surprise these pencils have long been a favourite among makeup artists—they’re reliable, easy to work with, and perform well no matter how you use them.
Is It Worth The Money?
Yes—100%. These pencils aren’t just a good lip liner; they’re one of the most versatile makeup products you can own. You can use it as a lip liner, eyeliner, cream eyeshadow, blush, or even to contour areas like your nose, so you’re getting far more than a single-use pencil.
I own almost every shade, which probably says everything you need to know. They’re creamy, easy to blend, and long-lasting, and I find myself reaching for them constantly. If you’re looking for a product that can do it all, this one is definitely worth adding to your makeup bag.
Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil, $35.50, sephora.ca
Disclosure: This product was gifted, but I am under no obligation to share a positive review. All opinions are entirely my own and based on my honest experience. This post also contains affiliate links; if you choose to purchase them, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support the content I create. Thank you for your support!
Photo courtesy of Sephora. Graphic made by Mursal.